Amanda Pendolino
May 17, 2013

Mariah Carey Accused of Horrific Lip-Syncing on ‘American Idol’ Finale (VIDEO)

Mariah Carey sang a medley of hits on last night’s American Idol finale … or did she?

Fans have accused the seasoned pop star of lip-syncing — badly. Watch this video and judge for yourself:

Viewers took to Twitter to express their disapproval of the performance, which included “Hero,” “My All,” “Vision of Love,” “Make It Happen,” “We Belong Together” and Mariah’s new single, “Beautiful.”

However, Mariah’s rep told Entertainment Tonight that she was singing live, as you’d expect a rep to do. What do you think? Was the singer pulling an Ashley Simpson, or was her live performance legit?